Using WritingFix's Post-Its
during Independent Reading Time
a testimonial from Alice Parker, Nevada teacher
Last spring, I had the pleasure of attending a teacher in-service course offered by the Northern Nevada Writing Project. Corbett [Harrison] and the other presenters taught us how to open the Post-it files on-line and print them on actual Post-It Notes®, which was great fun.
One of the other attending teachers didn't care for the Post-Its being printed on real Post-Its. She reported to our class that all the Post-Its fell off as soon as the drafts went into her students' messy desks. We all laughed, because that made a lot of sense to us. Corbett suggested that, if we have similar student desk conditions, instead of printing on sticky Post-Its, we print the sheet on colored Xerox paper, cut the Post-It Notes® out, and staple one to our students' drafts. A good compromise.
But I didn't want to lose the idea of having them on real Post-It Notes®. My kids like real Post-Its. They got excited when I passed them out with printing on them already. An idea occurred to me. It was my own compromise! What if, during my students' independent reading time, they attached a [trait] Post-It to their library books, and at the end of reading time, they had to rank their authors' use of one of the traits?...
(Click here to print and read Alice's entire testimonial.) |
Ranking versus Rating with the Post-its
a testimonial from Betty Flagg, Texas teacher
I had a huge "ah-ha" last week when using your Post-it templates. I realized that I had never thought carefully about the word "rank" on the instructions. I guess I am a little slow!
I had been allowing my students to "rate" the five skills, which gave them permission to give themselves all 3's or 4's, which I noticed were the numbers they used the most.
I realized that "rank" meant that each student should only have one 1, one 2, one 3, one 4, and one 5. This is what the verb "rank" was actually asking them to do.
My students and I had a great discussion about the difference between "rank" and "rate," and when I asked them to start ranking their skills instead of rating them, they found it much harder to do. But it was a good kind of difficulty for them; I think they had become lazy about applying the language of the Post-its to their own writing.
My students had to decide which skill (of the five) was their strongest and which was their weakest and where the others fell in between. My best writers and my writers who struggle had to go through the same process. This "ah-ha" has made me re-think how I'll use these Post-its again next year. Thanks!
|